★★★★★

First time coming here - I’d definitely come back! The flavor is there for sure. Jumbo wings are a must have - best wings we’ve had in a while. The meatballs were soo good, that was my favorite. No picture unfortunately since I wasted no time eating it. Sicilian Little Italy - very bready, think deep dish. I liked it, my family wasn’t crazy cause it was too much bread. I guess it would have been better if there was maybe a little more sauce but at the end of the day, I’d assume you order the Sicilian if you want more bread. Da Bronx - this was my family’s favorite. Very flavorful meaty pizza. Don Gio - flavorful, we were happy we went with the thin crust. I think it balances all the flavors well. New York Size pizza - this is just a cheese pizza basically which is great for the kids. Even we enjoyed it.

★☆☆☆☆

As a native New Yorker, this is not it whatsoever. Pizza was old and just thrown in the oven to warm it up before served to us. Super dry and burnt. Paid $10.99 for the lunch special. Which isn’t a bad price but the slices I got were small portions and In New York you can get 1 slice (bigger than the size of the two slices from here put together) with a drink and still pay less. Overall do not recommend. This place does a poor job representing New York pizza.

Reviews on Google help Giovanni's Old World New York Pizzeria get discovered. Takes 60 seconds.